來源： nascompares.com/2025/06/02/i-went-to-synology-hq-and-asked-about-hard-drives 重點就是作者拜訪了Synology HQ，重點擺在為什麼25年開始的個人用NAS要限用自家硬碟 細節大家應該都不太想聽，重點就是下面這兩段 該文引用了Synology Regional Sales Manager的文並提到確認第三方硬碟清單會在未來 提供 The article also mentioned that Synology-certified drives undergo over 7,000 hours of testing, and systems using those drives reportedly experience 40% fewer failures than those using uncertified media. Additionally, Synology claims that severe storage anomalies have dropped by up to 88% in systems following its compatibility policy. Although Chang confirmed that third-party compatibility may expand in the future, it will only do so under strict adherence to Synology’s internal benchmarks. These statements align with Synology’s position during the HQ tour, further emphasizing a shift toward a closed, highly controlled ecosystem that prioritizes consistent performance over hardware flexibility. 然後作者並未提出證據或具體來源但提供了下面的訊息 My biggest issue with all this is that, almost certainly, we are going to see Seagate, WD, Toshiba and more slow (slooooooooowly) appear on the compatibility lists for a number of the 2025 generation of devices over the coming months. So, what was all this for? The PR damage and likely early sales damage of the Synolgoy 2025 Series because of this change of support I would estimate is going to be pretty substantial – and all the reports and reactions to this online are not going to go away as soon as a Seagate Ironwolf or WD Red drive appears on the support lists. Also, Synology work on these devices for a very, very long time before launch – why is all this happening now – and not before launch. The cynic in me wants to just assume it was pure profitability and that Synology want to maximize profits, and if when this does begin to U-Trun ,that the brand can say that it was the plan all along. But whether that is true or not, the damage to the brand in the eyes of a substantial % of their long term fans is notable, and with many more players in the market (UniFi, QNAP, UGREEN and more) launching new products in Q3 and Q4 – is this all going to be a gamble by the brand that ends up costing them more than just leaving the support status quo where it was? Only time will tell. 這樣看來925+過年就可以買了(？ -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt-web.org.tw), 來自: 118.169.26.54 (臺灣) ※ 文章網址: https://ptt-web.org.tw/PC_Shopping/M.1750656513.A.A86

推 pmes9866: 怎麼了 不是對自己很有自信嗎 36.228.227.41 06/23 13:32

→ neilisme: 他不是知道錯了 而是知道自己快死了 61.216.64.210 06/23 13:34

推 nippleman: 可惜了桀驁不馴的氣質XD 42.75.153.12 06/23 13:39

推 jery1017: 識時務者為俊傑 不要為錢過不去 220.132.251.97 06/23 13:39

→ nippleman: 話說我上個月差點捏上s家硬碟 還好忍 42.75.153.12 06/23 13:40

推 Toth: 有錢人為啥都想包養 42.75.153.12 06/23 13:40

→ nippleman: 住 42.75.153.12 06/23 13:40

→ reaturn: 沒吧，我覺的他們家重心放在企業上是對的 218.166.151.76 06/23 13:45

→ reaturn: 家用小雞巴市埸讓給其他家不好嗎 218.166.151.76 06/23 13:46

推 multicopter: 如果真的開放第三方硬碟 剛買了1621111.255.110.147 06/23 13:50

→ multicopter: +會感覺不好 應該要買1825+的111.255.110.147 06/23 13:50

推 Asterix: 亞洲最大包養網上線啦111.255.110.147 06/23 13:50

推 shasen1236: 隨意吧，反正這家就算買最新的硬體也 60.251.66.59 06/23 14:00

→ shasen1236: 是非當下旗艦 60.251.66.59 06/23 14:00

推 Kowdan: 還是那桀驁不馴的樣子最適合群暉 61.115.168.134 06/23 14:05

推 lordmi: 其實專攻商業市場綁硬體是對的，有限的開 223.137.47.97 06/23 14:10

→ lordmi: 放黑群暉社群就能打死競爭者 而不是這樣 223.137.47.97 06/23 14:10

推 AdamShi: 我哥上包養網被我抓包.. 223.137.47.97 06/23 14:10

→ lordmi: 搖搖擺擺 223.137.47.97 06/23 14:10

→ luluking: 沒差，反正不會再買了 223.137.87.198 06/23 14:15

推 linfon00: 你 我 明 42.72.145.191 06/23 14:21

推 ICEFTP: 怕了唷！ 1.173.15.9 06/23 14:22

→ ICEFTP: 我都換成Asustor了 1.173.15.9 06/23 14:22

推 lezabo: 有人包養過洋鬼子嗎 1.173.15.9 06/23 14:22

推 pcfox: 華芸：謝丞相賜箭 36.231.116.27 06/23 14:29

推 theKusoStar: 哈 幹我就是剛買1621+ 1.170.14.12 06/23 14:30

推 tn00210585: 好奇，這間有所謂的自家硬碟？還是自 101.10.81.58 06/23 14:36

→ tn00210585: 家認證硬碟？少幾個字差很多噢 101.10.81.58 06/23 14:36

推 dos01: 從獲利的考量上來說 只要自家產品有不可替210.209.164.247 06/23 14:36

推 silberger: 有錢人為啥都想包養210.209.164.247 06/23 14:36

→ dos01: 代性 那不開放用第三方確實是有助於獲利210.209.164.247 06/23 14:36

→ dos01: 但前提是你的產品要有不可替代性R210.209.164.247 06/23 14:36

→ xbearboy: 以為自己大到夠資格收送驗費了嗎？111.249.173.233 06/23 14:37

推 dos01: 現在一大票競爭者 還有給人自組只求賣硬碟210.209.164.247 06/23 14:39

→ dos01: 的在旁邊削價競爭 要搞獨佔小圈圈的難度很210.209.164.247 06/23 14:40

推 xayile: 有人被洋鬼子包養過嗎210.209.164.247 06/23 14:40

→ dos01: 高210.209.164.247 06/23 14:40

推 z22771187: 進攻企業市場綁硬碟是正確的 61.222.164.125 06/23 14:49

→ z22771187: 公司機架式server硬碟全部都是綁的 61.222.164.125 06/23 14:50

→ z22771187: 一般人都轉freenas、truenas 61.222.164.125 06/23 14:51

→ x94fujo6: 查無此牌 114.33.176.49 06/23 15:09

推 cazo: 到底要多有錢才會想包養 114.33.176.49 06/23 15:09

推 felaray: 來不及了 這波傷害到許多信心 114.36.38.213 06/23 15:36

推 keltt: 他如果硬要限制用戶只能用他們家的硬碟， 136.23.35.35 06/23 15:43

→ keltt: 我以後就不買他們家的NAS了 136.23.35.35 06/23 15:43

→ keltt: 你們要綁自己家的硬碟，那就賣便宜點。夠便 136.23.35.35 06/23 15:44

→ keltt: 宜我就沒意見 XD 136.23.35.35 06/23 15:44

推 izilo: 包養SD = aSugarDating 136.23.35.35 06/23 15:44

→ x94fujo6: 有沒有可能 只是想騙進來再搞一次 114.33.176.49 06/23 15:44

推 traz04067: 反正我不會買了125.227.179.199 06/23 15:59

→ NanaMizuki: ㄏ118.170.208.211 06/23 16:06

→ E7lijah: 我看文章的說法怎麼像是群暉要把驗證第三 39.15.56.51 06/23 16:21

→ E7lijah: 方硬碟的工作&責任丟給硬碟廠們，而不是 39.15.56.51 06/23 16:21

推 SEDAP: 閨蜜上包養網還推薦我... 39.15.56.51 06/23 16:21

→ E7lijah: 群暉自己去提供相容性清單 39.15.56.51 06/23 16:21

推 menchian: 如果有打算升級網卡，那923還是比925好 61.223.184.30 06/23 16:21

→ menchian: 就是 61.223.184.30 06/23 16:21

→ NanaMizuki: 925+是升都沒得升118.170.208.211 06/23 16:29

推 magiclunar: 有沒有可能是群暉的行銷策略（陰謀）223.139.161.242 06/23 16:49

推 TUZom: 包養?223.139.161.242 06/23 16:49

→ magiclunar: ，慢一點開放除了攤提認證的成本以外223.139.161.242 06/23 16:50

→ magiclunar: ，另一方面可以讓舊的庫存品銷售一空223.139.161.242 06/23 16:50

→ magiclunar: ，我看最近這兩三個月很多舊21 22 23223.139.161.242 06/23 16:50

→ magiclunar: 的庫存品銷售幾乎全空或是賣得不錯223.139.161.242 06/23 16:50

→ arlfasamue: 驗證硬碟是誰要花錢..? 114.35.128.216 06/23 17:16

推 Jiulon: 台全最的包養SD上線啦! 114.35.128.216 06/23 17:16

→ arlfasamue: 硬碟廠怎麼會去管一間設備商.. 114.35.128.216 06/23 17:18

→ NoneWolf: 晚了就不要了 已經換他牌 嘻嘻 42.70.209.33 06/23 18:44

推 Ducklover: 應該比較像是看第三方硬碟廠有沒有想跑 42.70.45.62 06/23 19:08

→ Ducklover: 驗證送 件，有通過的話會提供出來 42.70.45.62 06/23 19:08

推 menchian: 現在很多高階主板都給5G，10G網卡價格也 223.138.147.54 06/23 19:15

推 laetuon: 現在包養網都這麼直接嗎 223.138.147.54 06/23 19:15

→ menchian: 下滑很多，離普及真的不遠，除非你一台n 223.138.147.54 06/23 19:15

→ menchian: as只想用個3年4年而已 223.138.147.54 06/23 19:15

噓 yun1019: 原廠硬碟 我不反對 反對的是價格= =220.141.203.160 06/23 19:51

推 guanting886: 群暉Synology那些說法沒有什麼說服 42.78.10.143 06/24 04:00

→ guanting886: 力 大家都知道你想推自有品牌（貼牌 42.78.10.143 06/24 04:00

推 slot365: 歐美包養真的很平常嗎? 42.78.10.143 06/24 04:00

→ guanting886: ）硬碟 但硬是說為了穩定度 只開放 42.78.10.143 06/24 04:00

→ guanting886: 認證過的硬碟真的說不過去 甚至不是 42.78.10.143 06/24 04:00

→ guanting886: 認證過的功能會被停用、不支援 42.78.10.143 06/24 04:00

推 guanting886: 靠杯 那怎麼解釋2025以前的NAS配的 42.78.10.143 06/24 04:02

→ guanting886: 硬碟都頭好壯壯穩定使用 大部分的採 42.78.10.143 06/24 04:02

推 colortea: 男友上包養網 該放生嗎 42.78.10.143 06/24 04:02

→ guanting886: 購都也是偏好的可以跑比較久的NAS碟 42.78.10.143 06/24 04:02

→ guanting886: 或更好規格的硬碟 42.78.10.143 06/24 04:02

推 guanting886: 這邊統計到的硬碟都沒在壞 只有容量 42.78.10.143 06/24 04:08

→ guanting886: 不夠未來會往上升 也沒什麼人怪你硬 42.78.10.143 06/24 04:08

→ guanting886: 體不好用還是不穩定 就一個調用作業 42.78.10.143 06/24 04:08

推 glenber: 是這個包養平台嗎 42.78.10.143 06/24 04:08

→ guanting886: 系統走軟RAID的NAS硬體是要不穩定到 42.78.10.143 06/24 04:08

→ guanting886: 哪裡？ 42.78.10.143 06/24 04:08

推 saito2190: 923+使用者含淚推 1.161.148.223 06/24 06:22

噓 daqdaqqq: 1621+怒噓 42.79.208.244 06/24 06:30

→ zxzx8059: 群輝先改善9xx+的電供暴斃問題吧= = 49.216.16.239 06/24 06:58

推 Kimbel: 交男友跟包養有什麼差別 49.216.16.239 06/24 06:58

→ shawncarter: 啊不是覺得自己很屌 36.230.94.44 06/24 10:41

推 rod1014: 918+繼續戰，看後面變化 114.34.187.225 06/24 13:02

推 tony5110: 我懷念你原本的傲氣114.136.129.175 06/24 13:10

推 menchian: 不過我是贊成強制弄相容性清單這類的，125.231.200.154 06/24 14:40

→ menchian: 但第三方廠還是得加入，當初有做這東西125.231.200.154 06/24 14:40

推 tale1890: 包養網到底在紅什麼?125.231.200.154 06/24 14:40

→ menchian: 我就不會買一堆WD的紅標3T搭416了，每隔125.231.200.154 06/24 14:40

→ menchian: 幾個月就壞軌一顆真的是惡夢125.231.200.154 06/24 14:40